Sunday, March 09, 2008

Good Medicine

Just when you think there are only so many years of Medicine you can do before cynicism sets in, something happens that makes you remember why you chose to stick with it in the first place. Cynicism has many tactful medical labels; my personal favourite being, “I’d say the prognosis is guarded” (weasel words delivered with an inward grimace). A friend prefers “cautious optimism”. All of which are polite euphemisms for anything ranging from “You just might get better”, to “I don’t know”. At worst, both expressions implicitly mean, “You’re fucked, mate, but I don’t know how to tell you”.

And then someone walks in, all of 17, bright and vivacious and with laughing eyes and fiercely intelligent and a bit wary because she’s going to tell you that she’s stopped her meds. Before she sits down, you already know. You look at her, shrug inwardly, grin and ask, ‘You stopped ‘em, didn’t you?’ She can’t stop grinning, ‘How did you knooowww?!!!’

‘It’s obvious, you look a lot happier for a start. And they aren’t the best things to make you feel alert and bright, are they? And you are happy.’

Her mother, anxious about the whole situation and worried that I am going to say something dire, says hesitantly, ‘She just wouldn’t listen to me. She stopped it soon after she saw you last, but she tapered it over 3 weeks.’

I am about to throw up my hands and shrug, but then think otherwise. ‘That’s fine, you are the best judge of what’s good for you, and you’re fine without it and that’s all there’s to it, really. But no weed, okay?’

The relief’s obvious on their faces, ‘It wasn’t just weed, there was speed, LSD and MDMA, but I am never going there again’, she shakes her head, suddenly grave.

This is news to me, and a bit worrying. But her intent and determination are unmistakable. “You do LSD, you’re screwed; you know that, don’t you? Not everybody reacts badly to all this, but unfortunately, you do. We’ve already talked about it, yeah?”

She shakes her head several times, “No, never again, I should have learnt that in Ibiza, the first time”.

I believe her. But she has more up her sleeve, this one, “I am starting a job, at the school in ……”.

“Oh, great, fantastic, that’s good news”, I am already looking at the nurse from the specialist team, ready to wind up and hand over. They’ll keep an eye on her in the community for the next two years, just to make sure she’s fine.

“….and I’ve got a place at University, in Cambridge, and I’m starting in September, so the job’s only until then”.

I am startled, then astonished, then admiring, then very proud, “Wooooowwww! Coooool” I gawp at her. I am aware that I don’t sound like a doctor anymore.


She beams at me, shaking her head happily.

I digest the implications, and they are staggering. She’s mixed-race and working class, her mother brought her up alone, and she grew up between the inner-city and the rusting post-industrial end of the commuter belt. Both can be soul-destroying places. She had the worst kind of illness an ambitious and driven teenager could have, twice, for no other fault than experimenting with the usual stuff teenagers do in Ibiza and Brixton. But they had steel, these two, that much was obvious from the start. And that's part of the reason why I've stubbornly refused to label her with a stigmatizing diagnosis.

And now, this. Suddenly, I am happy being a doctor. A regular, jobbing, salary-drawing, non-paper-publishing, non-ambitious, non-academically-wheeling-dealing, not-sought-after, not-changing-the-world, will-shove-my-hand-in-and-unblock-the toilet-if-that's what's going to make the patient better doctor.

Just. A. Fucking. Doctor. It feels good.

10 Comments:

Blogger milieu said...

Wow...the ending was brutually honest! And overall a post I really enjoyed reading!
Guess the cynicism is there in every field though its admirable the kind of things medical doctors go through and still do this with heart.
Keep the Faith!

Monday, March 10, 2008  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

"A...not-changing-the-world...doctor."

I don't think that your patients would quite agree on that. Ask the 17-year old if you don't believe.

~N.

Monday, March 10, 2008  
Blogger nevermind said...

Hi, sreekumar, I try:) Thanks.

Hi N, yeah, know what you mean. But that experience has become so rare that I blog about it when it happens! Anyway, change in job might do the trick. Might.

Saturday, March 15, 2008  
Blogger bendinggender said...

i agree with n!
and don't all our jobs, education whatever come with dollops of drudgery? i do papers and stuff as part of work and hell..i get bored of my own writing often enough..

Sunday, March 16, 2008  
Blogger nevermind said...

nikita, iam yet to get bored of papers, and am astonished by how badly i reacted when the mere prospect of not writing them sometime in the distant future loomed into view. and i simply couldn't deal with a full caseload of clinical work where medicalizing suffering and prescribing pills was considered the norm, rather than addressing the socio-economic context that led to the distress and illnesses in the first place. i have no problem with drudgery, but when that is undertaken in a climate where defensive clinical practice and cynicism are the default positions, one begins to see the value of the (flush with funds) academic hospital, where practice is informed by research and people look at their work as careers and vocations with a sense of purpose rather than mere jobs. of course its not so simple and none of this is all or none or black and white. i intensely dislike the 'we're the best, take it or leave it' attitude of the institutes i have worked for (with the notable exception of one) and have clashed with it openly (acquiring a bad rep in the process)and the tokenism of the clinical work many western academic-medics do, but i would much rather be part of that than a system which accepts social defeat as the norm.

also, i naively assumed that rural england would be similar to rural india, but the health systems i worked for in rural india were optimistic, change-embracing systems that constantly adapted to new realities, unlike the static, intert, 'what can you do, after all?' culture of practice in rural england. hope you get my drift.

Wednesday, March 19, 2008  
Blogger bendinggender said...

hmm..maybe, no probably. this sort of stuff ought to be talked about face to face, you know!

Wednesday, March 19, 2008  
Blogger nevermind said...

i didn't mean systems actually; i meant organizational behaviour. and the systems i worked for in rural india were again, gold standard exceptions. come to think of it, Govt. PHCs were as cynical and defensive.i am being a spoilt bloody brat here, aren't i?

And yes, they ought to be, actually:)you've got mail.

Thursday, March 20, 2008  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Ah, nice to see a conversation in this space after so long! It's very interesting what you said about the medical systems in rural India. Would like to know more about that, whenever possible.

~N.

Thursday, March 20, 2008  
Blogger nevermind said...

okay, N, deal. For whatever my word is worth on this blog, which as we both know, is not very much:)

Thursday, April 10, 2008  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

:D :D

~N.

Saturday, April 12, 2008  

Post a Comment

<< Home

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 2.5 License.